Subscription Management

Changing plans without cancelling

I led the design of Change Plan, which lets Game Pass members upgrade or downgrade directly on their Xbox without cancelling.

The Game Pass plan picker on console: your current plan with Change plan and Keep plan, beside the plans you can move to
The Change Plan picker, shipped in the Xbox June 2024 Update.

Overview

Role

UX designer

Design timeline

Oct 2022 to Feb 2023

Team

2 designers, 1 engineer, 2 PMs

Release

Xbox June 2024 Update

Design wrapped in February 2023. Change Plan shipped in June 2024 after the team developed a tax estimation model to support plan changes.

Problem Switching plans could mean cancelling first

Game Pass members could upgrade on Xbox, but switching to a lower tier could mean cancelling and signing up again. Members who wanted a different plan had to go through a flow designed for people who wanted to leave.

Before

Xbox Settings on console
Xbox SettingsWhere members start
The subscription page with Change plan and Cancel subscription options
Subscription pageChange plan or Cancel
A screen saying Microsoft Edge needs to open, with a QR code to scan
QR codeFinish in Edge on another device
The upgrade plan picker showing only higher Game Pass tiers
Upgrade pickerShows higher tiers only
A screen asking Are you sure you want to cancel your Game Pass subscription
Cancel confirmationThe only way to a lower tier
Leaves the consoleMembers finish somewhere else
Upgrades onlyRuns on the Upgrade Plan Picker (UPP)
Cancel, then sign up againNo way to downgrade on console
Change plan Cancel subscription
Before: upgrades worked, but Change plan could send members off the console, and a lower tier meant cancelling and signing up again.

Goal

Give members a way to upgrade or downgrade on their Xbox without interrupting their membership.

Research What other subscriptions offer before cancellation

I compared how subscription services offer downgrades and pauses, explain which benefits members would lose, and show when those benefits end.

Competitive Analysis

Adobe CC, Amazon, Apple, Apple TV, Audible, Crunchyroll, Google, Headspace, Hello Fresh, Hulu, Mailchimp, Microsoft 365, Netflix, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation, Spotify, Xbox, YouTube TV

How 17 subscription services handle cancelling: which offer each option, and what share of them do
FeaturesCompaniesPercentageReference images
What you’ll be missingExplains what users will lose before they cancel
  • Adobe Creative Cloud
  • Audible
  • Amazon
  • Hulu
  • Netflix
  • Spotify
  • +4
55%
Downgrade planOption to choose a cheaper plan
  • Adobe Creative Cloud
  • Apple
  • Hulu
  • Netflix
  • Xbox
27%
Pause / skipOption to pause or skip for a certain time period
  • Hulu
  • HelloFresh
  • Mailchimp
  • YouTube
22%
Bargain dealOffers a sweet deal before fully cancelling
  • Audible50% off 3 mo
  • Headspace50% off 1 yr
  • Hulu40% off 6 mo
16%
Expires on next billingKeeps benefits until next billing cycle
  • Amazon
  • Apple
  • Apple TV
  • PlayStation
  • Nintendo Switch
  • Netflix
  • +5
61%
Cancel immediatelyCancels and refunds the subscription immediately
  • Xbox
  • Microsoft 365
11%
SurveySurvey asks why you want to cancel
  • Google
  • Hulu
  • Headspace
  • HelloFresh
  • Audible
  • Spotify
  • +3
50%

Favorites

Hulu

Audible + Amazon

Spotify

Our top picks:

Best cancellation experiences

Why?

Empathetic options to have more control: pause, downgrade, bargain deal

Why?

Lets users know how to make the most out of their credit + benefits before cancelling

Why?

Simple infographic visually shows how things will be different if you cancel.

The competitive analysis. Hulu, Audible with Amazon, and Spotify stood out.

What the others did

  • Explain which benefits end

    55%

    of services explained what people lose before they cancel.

  • Offer a downgrade or pause

    27%

    of services let people downgrade, and 22% let them pause or skip.

  • Keep benefits until the next billing date

    61%

    of services kept benefits running until the next billing date.

Solution One place to start a plan change

I designed a single entry point in Xbox Settings for both upgrades and downgrades. Members could start from Change Plan even though the two plan pickers stayed separate.

After

The subscription page in Settings, where Change plan starts
Change planFrom the subscription page in Settings
The Combined Plan Picker: the current plan pinned beside the other Game Pass plans
Combined Plan PickerCurrent plan pinned, Keep plan focused first
Upgrade Plan Picker (UPP)For a higher tier
Change Plan Picker (CPP)For any other plan
PaymentThe existing checkout
Plan changedMembership stays active
Upgrade Select
After: one picker, with each button routed to the right system. The broader subscription management work had three phases. Change Plan covered upgrades and downgrades. Pause Plan came second, followed by the cancellation redesign.

This prototype shows how members could review their plan options and make a selection with an Xbox controller.

Find Change Plan in Settings

Members can start an upgrade or downgrade from their Xbox subscription settings.

Choose a plan on console

Members can review and select another Game Pass plan with their controller.

Manage recurring billing

Members can manage recurring billing from the same page.

Impact Plan changes came to Xbox Settings

Change Plan shipped in the June 2024 Xbox update. Game Pass members could upgrade or downgrade on console without cancelling their subscription.

Read the announcement (opens in a new tab)

5% of members who started cancelling after the update switched to another Game Pass plan.

Accessibility Designed for a controller and a TV

Members navigate with a controller and may read the screen from across the room. In high-contrast mode, outlines and a prominent focus ring help members see which option they’re about to select.

Lessons What I learned leading the design

Make the design decision easy to trace

I learned to document why we gave members one starting point in Settings even though upgrades and downgrades used separate pickers.

Account for billing early

Members need an accurate price before confirming a plan change. For Change Plan, that made tax estimation a dependency for launch.